Joen Wolfrom’s Playing with Color: Elusive Shades Worth Capturing
Joen Wolfrom | January 6, 2012
A RARITY—-LUSCIOUS, RICH SHADES
The Shade Scale
There are four color scales in the world of color: pure color scale, tint scale, shade scale, and tone scale. During these next two weeks we’re going to investigate the shade scale.
A shade is created when black is added to a pure color. A shade can be slightly darker than its pure color, almost black, or it can be a color that lies anywhere between these two extremes. Every color that is a shade belongs to the shade scale.
An Important caveat: A shade NEVER has gray in its makeup—even a tiny bit. If there is any hint of grayness in a dark color’s makeup, it is not a shade. It’s a tone. Only black and a pure color can be present in a shade. Don’t be fooled into thinking a dark color is a shade because most darkened colors have a hint of grayness in them.
The Changing Colors
When you first add a touch of black to a pure color, the pure color becomes a bit darker. Also it begins to lose its intensity. It is not quite as brilliant as its pure form. As each bit of black is added, the color lessens its intensity and increases its darkness. Eventually the color will appear almost black—-with a hint of the pure color as a subtle influence.
You can probably see the effect of the black added to this green.
The color is darker than its pure color, but not dark enough to call it dark green.
No grayness is found in shades. Instead, they are a combination of the pure color and black.
Shade Names
Whenever the word dark or deep is placed in front of a color name, it indicates the color is a shade. Such examples are dark blue, dark violet, dark purple, dark green, deep violet, deep blue, deep green, and deep purple. Loosely speaking, relatively cool pure colors have shades that are fairly predictable in their darkened forms. They simply look darker. These most predictable shades come from the colors that move around the color wheel from green through the blues, violets, and on to magenta.
Shades that move from spring green to yellow to orange and on to blue-red are less predictable in their shaded form. In fact, shades of these warmer pure colors can be quite surprising. These shades rarely use dark or deep in their names, although occasionally you’ll find it used, as in dark red or deep red, Usually these shades have unique names that do not indicate their pure color origin. Examples are rust, brown, olive, avocado, and maroon,
Other shade names that you are probably familiar with are cranberry, grape, raspberry, teal, navy blue, and ink navy.
Pure colors are shown on this color wheel. All shades are darker than their pure colors.
Shades in Your Medium
If you are a painter, it should not be a problem to paint with shades of color. Simply begin with a pure-color paint and a clear, deep black paint with no hint of gray. The amount of black added will determine the darkness of the paint. Also, you can purchase a tube of shade paint. Either way, the paint should be rich in color.
It’s more difficult to find a shade if you are a quilter, weaver, fabric artist, or fiber artist because you are at the mercy of the manufacturer that dyes your material (cloth, yarn, etc.). To create a shade, the coloring process begins with a pure white material. This means the fabric must be bleached white before applying the dye.
Most fabrics begin their dyeing process in their natural unwhitened state. When the dye is applied to a non-white fabric or yarn, the result is not the same as when a bleached white fabric is used. This is because the natural hue of the gray-good influences the way the color looks on the fabric. It results in a gray cast to it. The more grayness in the natural color of the material, the more the color grays. If the original material is only slightly off-white, its influence will not be so great and the grayness will be subtle. Because most fabrics are dyed on unbleached fabric, most fabrics are toned—with a slight gray cast to them. This is why it is difficult to find fabrics that read as shades.
Making Do
Northern Lights by Joen Wolfrom
Whenever I find a shade fabric in a fabric store, I purchase it, as I never know when I need it. When I can’t find a beautiful, richly colored shade that I want (or need), I use a dark, slightly toned fabric as its substitute. There just aren’t enough shaded fabrics in existence, so substitutions are needed. In the Northern Lights quilt (above), I have used dark toned fabrics because I couldn’t find the appropriate shades. If you need to substitute a dark toned fabric for a shade fabric, select the fabric that is the darkest and richest of your possibilities. .
Below is a closeup of this quilt, giving you a better look at the darkest substitute fabrics used. Notice the darkest, least toned (grayed) fabrics provide interest. The fabric closest to being a shade is the dark blue one. Although I would have preferred using shades, I actually don’t mind the tonal variations of the darkest fabrics used. I try not to get too hung up on my inability to find a shade that I want. I have learned to buy them when I see them; then I can use them as needed—-that’s my hope anyway. I end up using more substitutes than shades, as you can well understand.
The Beauty of Shades
Using shades in your artwork provides visual strength and beautiful richness. Shades contrast well with tones and pure colors. Meredith Annett’s quilt Northern Lights (below) provides us with an example of how shades enhance a design with their deep, dark beauty. When you use shades, be certain to include light-valued colors in the design too. This will assure that your design can be clearly seen from a distance. Meredith did this so beautifully. I absolutely love this quilt with its rich beauty. (If you have the book Adventures in Design, you will find Meredith’s Northern Lights quilt in it, as well as other quilts of hers.)
Northern Lights by Meredith Annett from Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada
If you want to explore shades:
1. If you have a fabric stash, consider doing the following: Purchase a half-yard piece of the blackest black cotton fabric you can find. Next pull out your darkest fabrics from your stash. One at a time, place a dark fabric on the black fabric, so that you can see both of them clearly. Does the dark fabric look strong and luscious against the black fabric? Or does the dark fabric look slightly drab or veiled beside the black fabric. Does it lose its strength? If the color holds its own, it’s a shade. If it appears weaker, grayer, or not as intense as the black, it’s a tone. See how many shades you have in your stash.
2. If you work with fabric, yarn, or other fiber, go to the store and see if you can find a shade. Use your black fabric to help you determine whether a fabric is a shade or a tone. If you find a shade and you like it, consider buying it for later use. You may be surprised to find that your favorite store has no shaded fabric or yarn on its shelves. If you are a painter, did you find any shades amongst your tubes?
Let me know what you find in your stash. See you at the next post—more about the shade scale then. …..
Happy coloring!
Joen
Text and photography copyright © Joen Wolfrom
Joen is a color enthusiast who teaches and lectures on color. She has written three color books: Color Play, Visual Coloring, and The Magical Effects of Color. Her Studio Color Wheel is used to illustrate color concepts in many of these blog posts. She is also the designer of the 3-in-1 Color Tool. Her new book Adventures in Designis now available. Joen’s newest design tool, the Magic Design-Ratio Tool has just been released. All books and products are published by C & T Publishing.













Good Morning Joen,
I teach acrylic painting in a small studio here at my house. My students are wanting to learn more about color. I love your color wheel and thought this would be fun for them to do. I was wondering if you would object to me doing this? What about your blog on shades as well as some others?
I would promote your name and books but feel I must ask you first
Karen
Good Morning Karen,
The answer on all accounts is YES. My goal in writing this color blog is for people to learn more about color, to feel more comfortable with color, to better understand their reactions to colors, and to understand color interactions and illusions. So, I would be honored to have you use anything on my blog for teaching or helping your student. Also, thank you for giving me credit. I appreciate that. Have fun and let me know how things go.
Joen
As you probably know, there are instructions on the blog for painting the color wheel in three sections. These should help with your organization. Let me know how things work out. And thanks for sharing this information. I appreciate it.
Joen,
This was a great piece on shades–I do think we tend to find mostly tones, especially these days. Last year I was trying to make something using fabric that was 15-20 years old–very clear dark blue and I had a very hard time finding the gradations I wanted to go with it…all pretty toned fabrics available..
Thanks so much for sharing your knowledge and I am so glad I found your blog.
Cheryl
Thanks, Cheryl. I agree with you about the fabrics. I went through my entire stash last year and found no more than two handfuls of shades. I was more than a little amazed. You’re right—it’s getting harder to find shades than it was a decade or so ago. Joen
Joen,
Thank you for this article on shades. I always appreciate everything you have to say about color since I heard you speak years ago. This, in particular, is very helpful and well written. Thank you again for sharing your knowledge. Linda
Linda,
You are very welcome. Shades are so beautiful yet so hard to obtain in our medium. I wish it were not so. BTW, I like the flexible format of a blog with regard to color. It helps to supplement the information in Color Play—or perhaps even Visual Coloring. Talk to you later. Joen
Very interesting. I had a hard time finding ANY shades in my collection except blues. Not even among the blacks… Now, I have a new shopping focus. Thanks for the tip.
Hi Anthony,
I’m with you. I have so few shades in my stash now…..it’s amazing. Perhaps 1 or 2. The hunt is on!I used to have more, but I guess I have used them all up. Have fun shopping….
Thank you. For the first time I understand why some fabric either sticks out like a shiny thumb in a quilt of more toned colors, and others look ‘dirty’ in a quilt of shades. I actually found quite a few shades in my stash. Well, maybe 10%, but it felt like a lot. They’re primarily in my blues, purples, and Christmas fabrics. I’d love to find some reds. Now that I look at mine they all look muddy. Thank you again.
Hi Stacey,
You may be the winner of who has the most shades in your fabric stash. Congratulations! You’re right about how shades and tones can affect the visual outcome of a quilt. Dark Christmas red shades are so beautiful but really hard to find.
Hi Joen – I’m a dyer and quilter and love the 3-in-1 color tool. Plus I’ve seen the work by Kay Bachkai that grew out of one of your classes – you’re both very talented artists.
I was fortunate enough to take ‘Color Mixing for Dyers’ with Carol Soderlund. It gives a very scientific, controlled method of dyeing an incredible range of solid colors. Since there is no true, pure black dye in the Procion MX family, she had us mix a small portion of a color’s complement to the darkest value of the main color. Great results! I do really like your idea of putting our shades side-by-side with a pure commercial black. It’s another to-do for the list.
Hi Lisa,
Thanks for the good input about your dyeing experience. It’s all so helpful. Joen
[...] sparse in your collection. If you missed this earlier post about shades, do visit this first shade-scale post. I suggest you head for it either before or after you read this post, preferably [...]
[...] yellow, golden-yellow, and chartreuse. If you have not had a chance to read the initial post about shades or the following post about cool shades, you might want to visit these posts before reading this [...]
[...] recent posts discussing shades, consider reading at least the first post that discusses what shades are and how they can be difficult to find in certain mediums. It might be advantageous for you [...]
Joen,
I had not gotten on to your blog until now after you mentioned it while replying ( positively) to my request to use information from Adventures in Design for my professional development class at Quilt Canada. I have just had the most fun reading through your lessons on shades. Thank you so much for sharing all your knowledge.
Thanks, Kathy. I’ll be putting out a new post very soon. Joen